The May 5 lottery flipped the draft on its head. Toronto jumped 4 spots to land the #1 overall pick. San Jose jumped 7 to #2 — the second-largest jump in the lottery era. Vancouver, with the best pre-lottery odds at 18.5%, fell to #3. Two trade protections triggered (TOR keeps the pick, FLA keeps the pick). Below: full 32-pick post-lottery order with reasoning, consensus cross-checks, and where teams might go off-board.
Run Your Own Mock → See All 410 ProspectsThe 2026 class is top-heavy. One generational talent, three or four top-pair blue-chippers, and then a sharp drop into the teens. With the post-lottery order finalized, the question isn't who goes #1 — Toronto picks McKenna — it's whether San Jose follows the consensus board with Stenberg or swings for upside, and whether Vancouver gets the right defenseman at #3.
Toronto won the lottery with 8.5% odds, jumped 4 spots from #5 to #1, and triggered the top-5 BOS protection — keeping the pick they would have otherwise sent to Boston. The selection itself is locked: McKenna is the generational forward this draft was built around. 46 points (13G 33A) in 30 NCAA games at Penn State. Vision and two-way play are the separators. The Leafs front office is looking at a franchise-altering pick they didn't expect to make.
San Jose jumped 7 spots — the second-largest jump in the new lottery era — and lands a top-2 talent for the third straight draft (Will Smith, Macklin Celebrini, now Stenberg). 32 points in 38 SHL games is record-setting pace for a draft-eligible. Pair Stenberg with the Sharks' existing forward depth and the rebuild just accelerated by 18 months. Off-ice noise from December didn't move most boards.
Vancouver had the best pre-lottery odds at 18.5% but slid to #3 when both winners jumped past them. The consolation prize: a franchise right-shot D. Verhoeff is the rare 6'4" defender who skates like he's 6'0", and he does everything well. 20 points in 30 NCAA games as a true freshman at North Dakota. Drew Doughty comp — body type plus reading the game. The Canucks could swing for Reid here, but Verhoeff is the floor pick that fits their D-pipeline gap.
Chicago dropped 2 spots after the lottery, but #4 is still elite tier. Reid pairs with Bedard and Frondell to give the Blackhawks a generational forward + top-pair D combo. 47 points in 42 OHL games is the offensive engine Verhoeff doesn't have. Backward mobility is the question mark, but his WJC tape (20+ minutes for USA) answers some of it. If skating cleans up, this is Makar-lite.
The Rangers slid 2 spots and land Smits — the Latvian D who surged up boards all season. Led Latvia in WJC ice time (23:40). Hedman-lite comparisons for the combination of size, mobility, and defensive poise. The Rangers' D pipeline gets a major boost; Smits could reasonably be NHL-ready by 2027-28. This was a Toronto pick on every pre-lottery mock — now it's New York's franchise piece.
Calgary dropped 2 spots and gets a center prospect with the rare combo of bloodlines + production. Manny Malhotra's son, Steve Nash's nephew — but the tape backs it up: 53 points in 39 OHL games with Brantford. Two-way game plus elite compete level. Fills the Flames' biggest organizational need (top-six C) and fits their identity perfectly.
Seattle dropped 1 spot but still lands a top-10 talent. Carels leads all WHL defensemen in scoring. Smooth skater who can run a power play. Youngest player on Canada's WJC roster — that's the tell for where scouts are on him. Fits Seattle's identity as a team that drafts complete hockey players, not just upside swings.
Winnipeg dropped 1 spot but gets the motor center who thinks the game at a high level. Not the flashiest prospect in this range but the one most likely to play 600+ NHL games. Fits the Jets' organizational philosophy — function over flash — and gives them a future top-six C to slot in behind Scheifele's window.
Florida kept their #9 pick — the top-10 CHI protection on the FLA→CHI conditional triggered, so the pick stays in Florida. The Panthers add the best remaining goal-scorer to a system that just won the Cup. Belchetz gives Florida a legitimate top-six finishing winger to develop behind their current core.
Nashville stayed at #10 (no lottery movement) and lands the first pick outside Tier 1. Björck is the best Tier 2 name on the board. Year-over-year growth in the Swedish ranks is the separator. Slots into the Predators' rebuild as a future top-six C with high hockey IQ.
Picks 11–32 compressed for readability — full write-ups in the HMD Mock Draft Simulator.
Best remaining right-shot D with real NHL projection. Blues add a top-pair-track defenseman.
High-skill C with size. Slots behind Hughes/Hischier to give the Devils three forward generations.
Modern D profile — skating and exit passes. Isles pivot from the consensus C run to grab a needed RD.
DET→STL conditional triggered — Blues add a second first-rounder. Kamloops scorer with size and shot.
First pick outside the lottery — Kings get the QMJHL D-prospect they've been targeting.
Caps' second first-rounder. Big-bodied Boston College LW with two-way game.
Picks 19–32 (lightning round):
Every mock has three or four guys who'll go earlier than the consensus says. Names to watch on draft night:
This mock aligns closely with consensus through the top 5 — McKenna at #1 to Toronto is locked across every public board now that the lottery is decided. Divergences start in the 6-10 range:
See the HMD Consensus Rankings page for the side-by-side with Tankathon, TSN, Ferrari, Button, and 6 other sources.
Every mock starts with four inputs and closes with one override:
Run your own 2026 NHL Mock Draft with the HMD Simulator — pick as any of 32 teams, propose trades, go 7 rounds deep. Now updated with the May 5 post-lottery draft order.
Start Mock Draft →Next update: post-Memorial Cup (late May 2026) with combine + pro day data factored in. Bookmark this page.